Education Is Overrated
Give a man a fish and he’ll eat for a day. Teach him to fish and he’ll eat for a lifetime.
That’s a lie.
I served in the Peace Corps in Guatemala. For want of better land, subsistence farmers there plant on horrendous slopes. Topsoil that took a century to develop is washed away in a few years. And without fertile soil, your crops can’t grow, and ….
So I energetically entered the education business. I taught people conservation methods that would save their land from rapid destruction. They loved me, and they learned. But almost nobody put the simple techniques into practice.
Education failed. I taught ’em how to fish, and they couldn’t be bothered.
No doubt you encounter the same thing all the time. You share a great benefit with someone, and they just don’t take action.
Education failed.
You probably do it yourself. Have you ever abandoned a New Years resolution you knew would really be good for you?
Education failed.
Whether it’s for community benefit or personal improvement, awareness is worthless until there is action.
I will show you what delivers success. Your missions, the good things you want for others and yourself, will triumph when they and you take action.
Most folks will say it all depends on motivation, self-discipline. Once you have the information (education), call upon your fortitude and good sense to get it done.
That’s the hard way. And it usually fails. (Refer to your abandoned New Years resolutions.)
My friend BJ Fogg, a professor at Stanford University, developed a simple model. There are three ingredients that must be in place for someone to take action.
Consider answering your cell phone. You won’t answer unless it rings. One of the three essential elements is a cue to act, or a trigger.
Sometimes you can’t—say you’re in the shower or at the movies. That’s another factor: ability.
And sometimes you just don’t want to talk to the person right then. The want-to factor, motivation, is the third ingredient.
With these three things simultaneously in play, in the right measure, behavior will occur. Without them, it won’t.
Education speaks only to motivation. And it’s not even the kind of motivation that usually leads to the desired behavior. Despite common wisdom, only machines, not people, always base their decisions on rational argument. Further, education ignores two of the three necessary pieces.
Here, then, is the recipe for success. Here, in simple terms, is how to get people to do stuff.
• Be sure that there is a specific cue to act. It might be reminder signs or some signal. Tying the new action to something in your existing schedule is often the most effective trigger.
• Make the right action the easiest action. Eliminate or reduce the barriers. (Conversely, if you are trying to cut down on a behavior, make it harder to do.) That’s the ability part.
• The want-to factor is essential, but the things that actually motivate people to action are often surprising. For example,we humans are hard wired to avoid losing things we treasure, so fines and bets can be powerful. Desire to fit in with peers and public commitment are often effective. And just a triumphant fist in the air actually provides a chemical reward that makes maintaining a behavior easier.
That’s it. Instigation to kick into gear, ability, and the want-to factor.
Unless, if course, you have no interest in follow-through. If your only aim is awareness, education works great. As for me, I usually want to see something happen.
Say you want folks to protect their farmland from erosion, or to use greener transportation. Or you want to get into a flossing habit. Perhaps you have a music student who needs to practice regularly. These require behavior change, not education. All it takes is the right combination of a spark to set it in motion, can-do, and want-to.
So if you need community action and you are thinking about using an awareness campaign, please reconsider.
And if you’re planning on launching a self-improvement effort armed only with your willpower and the knowledge that it’s a good thing to do, give a second thought.
Let me know how I can help.
Join with thousands who use these techniques to develop life-improving habits, and organizations around the globe who work to make the world a better place. (Motivation)
It’s easy—use the comment section immediately below. (Ability)
What’s lacking? A trigger. So on the count of three, write me a note in the comment box. One… Two…